THE University of St Andrews is investigating complaints that the performance of a teenage composer’s symphony was drowned out by a disco run by an exclusive womens club.
Charlotte Harding, 18, had travelled from Yorkshire with her family to hear the university’s symphony orchestra perform Voyage: A Concerto for Soprano Saxophone, which she wrote while at school.
But the thrilling prospect of hearing her piece played in the 1,000-seat Younger Hall, the main concert venue in St Andrews, was spoilt when a disco beat broke into the music.
The noise pollution came from an event run by the Lumsden Club, an “elite ladies” society that prides itself on social and charity parties, which was staging a noisy fund-raiser nearby.
The university is now reviewing what happened and the way events are scheduled, after a letter of complaint from the concert’s organisers.
“We are looking in to the circumstances of the complaint, into all the circumstances of the events that evening,” a spokesman said.
Miss Harding wrote her saxophone concerto while at school as part of her A-levels. Her music teacher, Richard Ingham, a visiting lecturer at St Andrews, brought it to the attention of the university.
The Music Society Symphony Orchestra was brought on board, and the piece was included in a Sunday evening concert alongside works by Leonard Bernstein, Aaron Copland and Antonn Dvork.
Miss Harding’s mother Amanda said: “We travelled up from Yorkshire full of high hopes. We were in awe, as it was just so exciting and a once-in-a-lifetime experience for Charlotte. We were all just bursting with excitement.”
But as the concert got under way, so did a loud dance beat.
“It was all right when the orchestra played loudly but, during the quieter bits of music, you couldn’t hear anything but the disco,” said Mrs Harding.
“It was such a shame, as they had hoped to record it for Charlotte to keep but, obviously, the noise of the disco meant that just wasn’t possible.
“It was still a wonderful evening, but I would have to say the noise did detract and mar it,” she said.
Staff reportedly asked the Lumsden Club to turn down the music at their party in a marquee on the nearby lawns of St Salvator’s Hall, the residence where Prince William boarded when he was at the university.
The concert’s conductor blamed “disastrous scheduling”. She said: “I am extremely angry at the distress caused to the players in the orchestra, to Charlotte Harding and Richard Ingham, and to the students of the Lumsden Club running the charity fund-raising event, and members of the audience whose enjoyment of the concert was ruined.”
Founded in 2001, the women-only Lumsden Club promises a good time for good causes.
The club hosts Pimms Parties and Top Gun Nights, but also prides itself on supporting children’s and cancer charities.
It is named after Louisa Lumsden, the founder of St Leonard’s School and a suffragist, and described as “the first prominent female figure within the University of St Andrews”.
No-one from the club responded to requests for comment yesterday.
The club has up to 40 members. Each year it invites “nine outstanding first year ladies” to join. They can sign up for interviews at a drinks night.
The club’s website states: “We host fun social and charity events throughout the university calendar and make a difference within the community.”
The poster for a coming Top Gun Night features a sexy photo of Tom Cruise and the dress code is “Take My Breath Away”.
In the past six years, the club has raised money for charities including Maggie’s Cancer Relief, Kids in Need of Education and the Children’s Hospice Association Scotland.